Rent vs Buy Calculator (Net Cost and Break-Even)
Put a real number on the rent-or-buy decision: the net cost of owning after the home is sold, the net cost of renting, and the month the two curves cross.
Renting and buying spend money in different shapes: rent is a steady outflow that never comes back, while buying front-loads cash and property costs but returns equity when you sell. This calculator adds up every monthly outflow on each side and subtracts the net sale proceeds, so the comparison is dollar-for-dollar. On the default inputs — a $400,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% for 30 years, 1.2% property tax, 0.35% insurance, 1% maintenance, 3% appreciation, and $2,000 rent growing 3% a year — the mortgage payment is $2,022.62 and the all-in ownership cost in year one is $2,872.62 a month. Over 10 years owning costs $277,366.60 net of the sale versus $275,133.10 of rent, so renting is ahead by $2,233.50; the two paths cross at 10 years 4 months.
Rent vs. Buy Formulas
- Mortgage payment:
PMT = L × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)withL = price − down payment,r = APR ÷ 12, andn = years × 12— the sharedFinCalc.monthlyPaymentengine. - Loan balance at month
m:Bm = Bm−1 × (1 + r) − PMT, walked month by month, floored at zero when the loan is paid off. - Property costs:
(tax % + insurance % + maintenance %) ÷ 12of the home's value at that month, where the value grows asprice × (1 + appreciation)m ÷ 12. - Opportunity cost of the upfront cash:
(down payment + closing costs) × ((1 + return)m ÷ 12 − 1)— what that cash would have earned if invested instead. - Net cost of owning at month
m:upfront + Σpayments + Σproperty costs + opportunity cost − (home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance). - Net cost of renting at month
m:Σ rentywhererenty = starting rent × (1 + rent growth)year. - Break-even horizon: the first month where the net cost of owning is less than or equal to cumulative rent. It is searched month by month up to 50 years.
How this comparison works
Most rent-versus-buy arguments compare a mortgage payment with a rent check. That comparison is wrong in both directions. A mortgage payment contains principal that comes back to you as equity and interest that does not; renting contains neither, but it also carries no property tax, no roof, and no 6% commission when you leave. The only fair comparison is net cost: everything each path takes out of your pocket, minus everything it hands back.
So this page charges the buyer for the down payment, closing costs, every mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, and maintenance, and the opportunity cost of the cash tied up at closing. It then credits the buyer with the home's appreciated value less selling costs, less whatever is still owed on the mortgage. The renter is charged rent, grown once a year, and nothing else. Whichever total is smaller at the horizon is the cheaper path for that horizon.
The output is not a verdict on whether to buy. It is a dollar figure under stated assumptions, and the assumptions are in the inputs for a reason — change the appreciation rate by two points and the answer can move by a decade.
What each side actually pays
The default case is a $400,000 home bought with $80,000 down and $12,000 of closing costs, held for 10 years. Year-one ownership costs $2,872.62 a month: $2,022.62 of principal and interest plus $400.00 of property tax, $116.67 of insurance, and $333.33 of maintenance. Rent starts at $2,000 a month and rises 3% a year.
| Cost Component (10 years) | Buying | Renting |
|---|---|---|
| Cash at closing (down payment + closing costs) | $92,000.00 | $0.00 |
| Mortgage payments / rent paid | $242,714.12 | $275,133.10 |
| Property tax, insurance, maintenance | $118,823.13 | $0.00 |
| Opportunity cost of the upfront cash at 5% | $57,858.31 | $0.00 |
| Less: net sale proceeds after 6% costs and loan payoff | −$234,028.95 | $0.00 |
| Net cost over 10 years | $277,366.60 | $275,133.10 |
The buyer's side accumulates $453,537.25 of actual cash out over the decade — $92,000.00 at closing, $242,714.12 of mortgage payments, and $118,823.13 of property tax, insurance, and maintenance — plus $57,858.31 of foregone investment growth, against $275,133.10 of rent for the renter. Nearly half of the buyer's cash returns as net equity when the home is sold at $537,566.55 and the $271,283.60 remaining loan balance is paid off ($234,028.95 net). After that credit the two paths land within $2,233.50 of each other: almost a dead heat over ten years, with the entire result resting on the appreciation assumption.
The break-even horizon
Buying usually loses early and wins late, because the up-front cash and selling costs have to be absorbed before appreciation and principal paydown catch up. The default case crosses over in month 124 — 10 years 4 months. The shape of the two curves explains why:
| Year | Cumulative Rent | Net Cost of Owning | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $24,000.00 | $60,379.69 | Renting by $36,379.69 |
| 3 | $74,181.60 | $109,022.74 | Renting by $34,841.14 |
| 5 | $127,419.26 | $157,472.24 | Renting by $30,052.98 |
| 7 | $183,899.09 | $205,673.97 | Renting by $21,774.88 |
| 10 | $275,133.10 | $277,366.60 | Renting by $2,233.50 |
| 15 | $446,373.93 | $394,503.85 | Buying by $51,870.08 |
| 20 | $644,888.99 | $507,074.18 | Buying by $137,814.81 |
The owning curve rises fast at first — $36,000.00 of closing and selling costs before the first mortgage payment — then flattens as principal accumulates and appreciation compounds. Rent keeps climbing at 3% a year, so its slope is the one that steepens. At year 15 the buyer is ahead by $51,870.08; at year 20, by $137,814.81.
Break-even sensitivity: appreciation and property tax
Two assumptions move the break-even horizon more than anything else you can type. Appreciation changes both the equity the buyer walks away with and the property costs charged along the way; the tax, insurance, and maintenance rate changes the monthly carrying cost.
| Appreciation Rate | Break-Even Horizon | Net 10-Year Cost of Owning | Cheaper at 10 Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | 26 years 5 months | $389,856.03 | Renting by $114,722.93 |
| 1% | 22 years 4 months | $355,809.84 | Renting by $80,676.74 |
| 2% | 16 years 5 months | $318,407.57 | Renting by $43,274.47 |
| 3% (default) | 10 years 4 months | $277,366.60 | Renting by $2,233.50 |
| 4% | 6 years 3 months | $232,383.92 | Buying by $42,749.18 |
| 5% | 4 years 1 month | $183,134.90 | Buying by $91,998.20 |
Three points of appreciation — 0% versus 3% — turn a 26-year break-even into a 10-year one, and a $114,722.93 win for renting into a near draw. Because nobody knows a home's future appreciation, the honest use of this table is to ask how much appreciation the buy case needs to work rather than to pick the row you like.
| Assumption Changed | Value | Break-Even Horizon |
|---|---|---|
| Property tax (default 1.2%) | 0.8% | 8 years 3 months |
| Property tax (default 1.2%) | 1.8% | 14 years 4 months |
| Property tax (default 1.2%) | 2.5% | 20 years 5 months |
| Selling costs (default 6%) | 0% | 5 years 6 months |
| Selling costs (default 6%) | 10% | 12 years 9 months |
| Investment return (default 5%) | 3% | 7 years 8 months |
| Investment return (default 5%) | 7% | 16 years 8 months |
Higher property tax and higher selling costs both push the break-even further out, because they are pure costs with no equity behind them. A higher return on the cash you would otherwise invest does the same: at a 7% investment return the renter's $92,000.00 of foregone growth is large enough to delay the crossover to 16 years 8 months, while at 3% it arrives at 7 years 8 months.
When renting wins
- Short horizons. Closing costs are 3% in and 6% out; a two-to-three-year stay rarely earns them back, whatever the market does.
- High price-to-rent ratios. Paying 25 times annual rent for a home means the rent check is cheap relative to the ownership cost. The default 400,000 / 24,000 ratio is 16.7×; at 25× the break-even moves out by years.
- Low or negative appreciation. The 0% row above is the honest stress test: without appreciation, owning is a 26-year proposition even with a 6.5% mortgage paying down principal.
- High carrying costs. Property tax at 2.5% of value, expensive insurance in a catastrophe zone, or a home that needs a new roof all lengthen the break-even.
- Money that can earn more elsewhere. The larger the down payment and the higher the return it could earn invested, the more the renter's alternative is worth.
Worked examples
Example 1: $400,000 home, 20% down, 10-year horizon (default)
Enter the defaults: Home Price = 400000, Down Payment = 80000, Mortgage Rate = 6.5%, Loan Term = 30, Property Tax = 1.2%, Insurance = 0.35%, Maintenance = 1%, Appreciation = 3%, Closing Costs = 3%, Selling Costs = 6%, Monthly Rent = 2000, Rent Growth = 3%, Investment Return = 5%, Horizon = 10:
- Loan and payment:
$400,000.00 − $80,000.00 = $320,000.00financed, payment $2,022.62 a month for 360 months. - Cash to close:
$80,000.00 + $12,000.00 = $92,000.00 - Property costs, month 1:
$400,000 × (1.2% + 0.35% + 1%) ÷ 12 = $850.00, so the all-in monthly cost is $2,872.62. - Ten-year payments:
$2,022.62 × 120 = $242,714.12of mortgage payments and $118,823.13 of property tax, insurance, and maintenance. - Sale at year 10: home value
$400,000 × 1.0310 = $537,566.55; after 6% selling costs, $505,312.56; minus the $271,283.60 loan balance, $234,028.95 comes back. - Net costs: owning $277,366.60, renting $275,133.10 — renting ahead by $2,233.50, with break-even at month 124.
Example 2: zero appreciation — the stress test
Set Home Appreciation = 0% and leave everything else at default. The home is still worth $400,000.00 after ten years, while property costs keep being charged on that flat value:
- Sale at year 10:
$400,000.00 × 0.94 = $376,000.00, minus the $271,283.60 balance, so only $104,716.40 comes back. - Net cost of owning at 10 years: $389,856.03 against $275,133.10 of rent — renting ahead by $114,722.93.
- Break-even: month 317 — 26 years 5 months, long after a 30-year loan has done most of its work.
This is the case that keeps the model honest: a mortgage is forced savings, but savings that lose 6% at the exit and pay 1.2% a year in tax are not automatically better than rent.
Example 3: 5% appreciation — buying wins early
Set Home Appreciation = 5%. The same payment and the same carrying costs now ride a faster-growing asset:
- Home value at year 10:
$400,000 × 1.0510 = $651,557.85, and after 6% selling costs, $612,464.38. - Net cost of owning at 10 years: $183,134.90 against $275,133.10 of rent — buying ahead by $91,998.20.
- Break-even: month 49 — 4 years 1 month.
Two extra points of appreciation move the crossover from year 10 to year 4. That sensitivity is the whole reason the inputs are yours to set: the calculator cannot know your market, only what you assume about it.
Example 4: the same home over a 5-year horizon
Set Comparison Horizon = 5 with the default assumptions. Nothing about the house changes — only how long you stay:
- Net cost of owning: $157,472.24 over 60 months versus $127,419.26 of rent.
- Gap: renting is ahead by $30,052.98 — about 13.5 times the 10-year gap of $2,233.50: halving the horizon roughly halves the recurring monthly flows, but the closing and selling costs stay whole because this model charges them once whatever the stay is.
- Break-even: still month 124, so a 5-year stay never reaches it.
The same purchase is a near-draw over ten years and a clear loss over five. Horizon is not a detail in this decision; it is half of it.
Assumptions and what this model does not do
- One sale at the horizon. The buy side is valued by selling the home on the last month of the horizon at the appreciated price, paying 6% of selling costs, and repaying the remaining loan balance. If you never sell, the equity is still yours but it is not cash, and the net cost number understates the illiquidity.
- Monthly rent, annual increases. Rent is charged monthly at the year's rate and stepped up once a year, not continuously. The security deposit is ignored on both sides, as is any renters insurance.
- Property costs scale with value. Tax, insurance, and maintenance are charged as percentages of the home's current value, so they rise with appreciation. That is conservative for the buy case; a jurisdiction with an assessment cap will do better.
- Opportunity cost covers upfront cash only. The $92,000.00 of down payment and closing costs is assumed to earn the investment return if not used to buy. The monthly cost difference is not invested in this model, so a disciplined renter who invests the gap will beat the rent curve shown here.
- No tax deduction, no PMI, no HOA. US mortgage interest and property tax can be partially deductible, which favors buying; mortgage insurance and HOA dues favor renting. Neither is modeled, so those effects are yours to weigh.
- No transaction friction on the rent side. Moving costs, lease break fees, and the value of flexibility are all excluded, even though they are often the deciding factor for a short stay.
- No single number is the answer. The break-even horizon is a function of assumptions you cannot know in advance — future appreciation, future rent growth, future investment returns. Read the sensitivity tables as a range, not as a prediction, and treat a break-even inside your horizon as a necessary condition rather than a reason on its own.
Related tools
- Payment detail. The Mortgage Payment Calculator adds PMI above 80% LTV and the lifetime interest bill.
- The amortization behind the balance. The Amortization Calculator shows how much of each payment is principal in any given month.
- Can you afford it? The Mortgage Affordability Calculator turns an affordable payment into a maximum loan and home price.
- Paying it off early. The Early Payoff Calculator prices extra payments against the interest saved.
- The opportunity cost, in full. The Compound Interest Calculator projects what the down payment would become if invested.
- Real versus nominal. The Inflation Calculator converts a nominal break-even into today's dollars.
Frequently asked questions
How is the break-even horizon calculated?
Month by month, the calculator accumulates what the buyer has paid (down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, insurance, maintenance, and the foregone investment return on the upfront cash) and subtracts the net sale value at that month (appreciated home value less selling costs, less the remaining loan balance). It does the same for cumulative rent, then reports the first month where the owning total is no longer larger. On the defaults that month is 124 — 10 years 4 months. The search runs to 50 years so a slow case still gets an answer, and if the owning curve never catches up the result reads "Not within 50 years".
Why does the calculator charge an opportunity cost on the down payment?
Because the $92,000.00 of down payment and closing costs is not free — it could be invested. At a 5% return it would grow to about $149,858.31 in ten years, so the model charges the buy side $57,858.31 for that foregone growth. Without this line, buying looks better than it is by roughly the return on the down payment. The model deliberately does not invest the monthly cost difference, which is why it may understate a disciplined renter.
Should I include property tax and maintenance in the comparison?
Always. They are the costs that separate a mortgage payment from a rent payment, and they never build equity. On the default home they add $850.00 a month in year one — $400.00 of property tax, $116.67 of insurance, and $333.33 of maintenance — pushing the true monthly ownership cost to $2,872.62: 42% above the mortgage payment and 44% above the $2,000.00 rent. A comparison that stops at the mortgage payment makes the gap look far smaller than it is.
What appreciation rate should I use?
Use a rate you can defend for your specific market and then test a range around it, because no other input moves the answer as much. In the sensitivity table, 0% appreciation pushes the break-even to 26 years 5 months while 5% pulls it in to 4 years 1 month. Long-run national house-price growth has historically run in the low single digits, but local markets vary widely and past appreciation does not obligate future appreciation — a zero row is the honest stress test, not the pessimistic one.
Does this rent vs buy calculator account for taxes or mortgage interest deductions?
No. Everything is after-tax cash in the sense that no deduction is credited to the buyer. In the United States, mortgage interest and property tax are deductible only if you itemize, and the standard deduction is large enough that many owners get no incremental benefit — which is why the model leaves it out rather than assuming a benefit. If you do itemize and your marginal rate is meaningful, the buy side improves by roughly your rate times the deductible interest, and the break-even moves earlier.
Is renting always worse over the long run?
No. Over very long horizons owning usually wins because the loan is paid off and the asset appreciates, but "usually" is not "always": at 0% appreciation the break-even sits at 26 years 5 months on the default home, and a high price-to-rent market can keep the renter ahead for far longer still. The relevant test is the break-even horizon against how long you will actually stay, plus the risk you are willing to carry. Rent buys flexibility and caps your housing cost at the lease; ownership buys a leveraged, illiquid, undiversified asset with a floor under your monthly payment only after the loan is repaid.